A 36-year-old man underwent direct laryngoscopy with routine general anesthesia for a knee procedure. Several days later, he experienced pain involving an ulceration along the medial aspect of the right mandible in the floor of the mouth. This evolved to a painful bony mass, and subsequently, a bony sequestrum was spontaneously shed. The initially misdiagnosed pathologic process occurred several more times on both sides of the mouth. A computed tomography scan eventually revealed large bilateral mandibular tori, a feature that likely predisposed the patient to this course of events. Pain in the floor of the mouth after airway manipulation should be carefully evaluated and the possibility of osteonecrosis considered.